22/01/2013
China (and Taiwan) has circulated the map of South China Sea with the U-shaped line (or nine-dotted line) in different internal documents and publications since 1948. However, it was not until 2009 that, for the first time, the People’s Republic of China included it in an official international document, namely in the Note Verbal sent to United Nations Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf to protest Vietnam and Malaysia joint submissions on the outer limit of their continental shelves in the South China Sea.
In recent years, China has increasingly used military and law-enforcement vessels, civilian ships and fishing boats to expand its presence within the U-shaped line and try to turn the waters within the line into Chinese maritime zones. At the same time, China has not yet officially clarified its claim and legal basis for the line, leading to a lot of speculations from the scholar community. There are different views and various possible interpretations of the legal status of the U-shaped line among Chinese and non-Chinese observers. This paper will examine the legal basis of all of these possible interpretations; try to find the official position of Chinese government regarding to the line and analyze reactions from international community. Then, it will conclude with suggestions for China (both mainland and Taiwan) to bring the line into conformity with international law, particularly the UNCLOS 1982, to defuse ambiguity and tension in the region.
(countinuing)
Read full text of this paper here
Recently, the Xinhua Institute (under China’s Xinhua News Agency) released a 33-page report titled “Historical and Legal Basis of China's Territorial Sovereignty and Maritime Rights in the South China Sea.” Xinhua Institute claims that this is a “comprehensive historical-legal assessment” intended to...
On September 9, 2025, the State Council of China enacted Document No. 87 [2025], approving the Huangyan Dao (Scarborough Shoal) Nature Reserve. Just a day later, China's National Forestry and Grassland Administration issued Communiqué No. 12, specifiying the size, scope, and functional components of...
After more than seven decades since its establishment in 1951, the Japan - US alliance has become a stable pillar of the security structure of the Indo-Pacific region. However, in the face of recent strategic changes, especially the rise of China and increasing instability in the region, Tokyo has been...
As the world moves past the midpoint of 2025, some might have the impression that the South China Sea appears comparatively calm. With major powers preoccupied by protracted conflicts elsewhere, such as Russia-Ukraine, Israel-Palestine, India-Pakistan, and most recently the tension between Cambodia and...
The Red Sea is one of the world's most heavily trafficked shipping lanes, with around 30% of global container traffic regularly passing through each year1. However, it also faces multiple maritime security issues. The 2023-2025 Red Sea crisis, which accumulates multiple layers of threats in the maritime...
There has not been a universal definition of “critical infrastructure” in maritime domain, but many can agree that such concept should include fixed platforms, including installations, and submarine cables . To protect these two types of infrastructure, the sole subjects of this essay, international...